(Native American Interest) (Watkins, Carleton E., photographer). Antique Stereograph (Stereoview) Titled "Indians of Arizona and New Mexico" [From the "Arizona - 1880" Series Checklist]. San Francisco, California: Carleton E. Watkins, 427 Montgomery St., [circa 1880]. A pair of 3-1/8" x 3" albumen photographs on the original orange card mount measuring 3-3/8" x 6-15/16" from "Watkins' New Series of Pacific Coast Views." Publication information is printed in black to the left and right margins recto, with the title printed to the lower margin recto; the lavender verso bears a modern pencil inscription, "Apaches."
The physical condition of this stereograph is graded (6/10) - VERY GOOD (utilizing a standardized 10-point scale for photographic prints and original works of art, indicating moderate or mild condition issues that attract the eye under normal viewing conditions). The albumen prints exhibit light, scattered spotting across both image surfaces, though they retain good clarity and deep tonal depth. The orange card mount remains structurally sound with minor edge wear along the recto margins and minor, uniform fading along the perimeter of the lavender verso.
Ethnographic Portraiture and Watkins' Southwest Expedition
This significant ethnographic stereoview documents a studio group portrait of two young Native American men, historically identified as Apaches. The composition captures the two figures seated against a neutral studio backdrop, adorned with painted geometric designs across their chests and wearing traditional hide leggings and moccasins. The figure to the left is posed holding a bow and arrow, with an intricately fringed quiver strapped across his torso, while his companion is seated with a trade hatchet resting across his knees.
The image reflects a complex layer of Western photographic production during the expansion of the transcontinental railroad systems. While commercially issued under the umbrella of Carleton E. Watkins' celebrated April 10 through May 18, 1880 expedition along the Southern Pacific Railroad line into Arizona, contemporary photographic scholarship has re-evaluated the exact origins of the series' New Mexico views. The studio setting and specific material culture visible in the portrait suggest an intersection of field work and corporate distribution common among late 19th-century frontier photographers.
Attribution, Photographic Bibliography, and Scarcity
The historical and geographic provenance of this view is clarified by specialized regional scholarship. According to Jeremy Rowe, a preeminent authority on early Arizona and Southwest photography, this specific view—formally cataloged under Watkins' "Arizona - 1880" series—relies on negatives likely acquired by Watkins from an uncredited contemporary operator. Rowe notes that while this view was commercially issued among the 100 titles in the "Arizona - 1880" checklist, Watkins himself is not documented traveling into the Santa Fe region during this specific interval.
Rowe’s analysis further refines the ethnographic attribution of the sitters, identifying them as likely Jicarilla Apache from New Mexico, which chronologically ties the production of the underlying negative to an earlier period between 1876 and 1879. Because Watkins' inventory suffered immense losses during subsequent corporate reorganizations and the complete destruction of his studio in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, original orange-mount "New Series" examples of his indigenous portraiture remain exceptionally scarce. Institutional databases and regional union checklists locate few surviving copies of this particular title, making it a critical index piece for the study of commercial tribal documentation.
AN EXCEPTIONAL AND SCARCE CARLETON E. WATKINS "NEW SERIES" ETHNOGRAPHIC RECORD, REVEALED THROUGH MODERN PHOTOGRAPHIC SCHOLARSHIP TO BE A RARE 1870s SPECIMEN OF JICARILLA APACHE PORTRAITURE, CONSTITUTING A VITAL ACQUISITION FOR RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS AND CONNOISSEUR COLLECTIONS FOCUSING ON THE HISTORY OF AMERICAN SOUTHWEST PHOTOGRAPHY.
# 001282